Moving to Chicago after graduation felt like a fresh start. New job, new apartment, and — I thought — a new wardrobe. I went a little crazy buying “grown-up” clothes and trendy stuff I saw online. Six months later, half my closet was full of regret purchases I barely wore.
This post is me being honest about the clothes I wish I could return. Not to shame anyone (I’ve been there), but to help guys in their early 20s avoid the same expensive mistakes while building a practical wardrobe.
If it looks good twice a week, it was worth buying. Most of these pieces failed that test hard.
The Big Mindset Shift I Needed
Right after graduation I was insecure about looking too young for my first real job. So I overcompensated — buying loud pieces, statement items, and things that were “fashionable” instead of useful.
Chicago weather and real office life quickly showed me what actually mattered. Fit, versatility, and comfort beat trends every single time.
Here are the specific items I regret most, in painful detail.
My Top Regret Purchases
1. Bright Patterned Button-Downs (The Loud Shirts)
I bought three “fun” patterned oxfords — one with palm trees, another with geometric prints. They looked cool in the fitting room but made me feel like I was trying too hard at work.
Worn maybe twice each. Now they sit in the back of my closet collecting dust.
Lesson: Stick to solid colors (navy, light blue, white) for office-appropriate shirts.
2. Skinny Distressed Jeans
Super tight, pre-ripped jeans that were trendy at the time. They were uncomfortable after two hours of sitting at my desk and looked sloppy with office layers.
Replaced them with straight-cut dark jeans that actually fit my legs and mix with everything.
Big regret: wasted $60+ on something that made me self-conscious.
3. Cheap “Statement” Bomber Jacket
Shiny black bomber with big logos. Looked edgy online but cheap and try-hard in daylight. It didn’t layer well and felt out of place in Chicago wind.
Replaced with the olive chore coat I wear constantly now.
4. White Sneakers with Thick Chunky Soles
The big dad-sneaker trend version. They made every outfit look bulky and less polished. My feet hurt after commuting.
Switched to simple low-top white canvas sneakers that go with everything.
5. Graphic Hoodies with Big Prints
Trendy branded hoodies that screamed “college guy who hasn’t moved on.” They didn’t layer under blazers and looked juvenile at after-work drinks.
Now I own one plain gray hoodie that gets worn on repeat.
What These Mistakes Taught Me
Every regret purchase had one thing in common: I bought for the idea of who I wanted to be instead of how I actually lived.
I was dressing for Instagram and hypothetical compliments instead of real Tuesday mornings at the office, train rides, and weekend coffee runs.
The clothes that survived were the boring ones — solid colors, good fit, versatile pieces. The 12-piece wardrobe I eventually built (and shared earlier) came directly from learning these lessons.
Buy less, repeat better. This became my new rule after these mistakes.
Better Alternatives I Bought Instead
Instead of patterned shirts → Light blue and white oxfords from Uniqlo/Target
Instead of skinny distressed jeans → Dark straight-cut jeans
Instead of flashy bomber → Olive chore coat and navy blazer
Instead of chunky sneakers → Clean white low-tops + brown leather shoes
Instead of graphic hoodies → Plain crewneck sweatshirts and merino sweaters
These swaps cost roughly the same total money but get worn 10x more often.
The Mental Cost of Regret Purchases
It wasn’t just the money. It was the daily frustration of opening my closet and feeling like I had nothing to wear. The low-level anxiety of “does this look okay?” that distracted me at work.
Once I cleared out the regrets and focused on reliable pieces, getting dressed became easy. I stopped thinking about clothes so much and just felt more confident.
Advice for Guys Right After Graduation
If you’re in that post-college phase right now:
Wait 48 hours before buying anything trendy.
Ask yourself: Would I wear this on a normal Wednesday?
Prioritize fit over style — even expensive clothes look bad if they don’t fit.
Start with basics before adding personality pieces.
Thrift or resale first for anything experimental.
You don’t need to look like a fashion guy. You need to look like a capable young man who has his basics handled.
Looking Back Now
I still make occasional bad purchases (that note in my phone is still growing), but far fewer. My closet is smaller, but every piece gets regular rotation. I feel more like myself — just a cleaner, slightly sharper version.
The clothes I regret weren’t terrible on their own. They just weren’t right for my actual life in Chicago with a normal job and budget.
If you’re reading this and have your own regret pile, don’t feel bad. Almost every guy I know went through the same phase. The important part is learning from it and moving toward pieces that actually serve you.
Clean beats complicated. Keep it simple, wear it often, and you’ll look better than 90% of guys your age.
What’s one clothing regret you have from right after graduation (or recently)? Share in the comments — you’re definitely not alone.
No letters yet — be the first guest to write.